A lead site membership priced before the leads, next to the alternative

Paying for leads that go nowhere? Work out your real cost per job

November 21, 2026

If you pay a lead site every month, here's a question worth answering honestly. How much did each job you actually won cost you?

Not each lead. Each job. On review sites, trades describe paying around £1,200 a year for a handful of calls, paying for contacts who never answered and finding the same job had gone to four or five other trades. Some of them only worked out the true cost when they added it all up at the end of the year.

This post gives you the sum to do on the back of an invoice. Then you can judge any lead source on the same terms, including your own website.

Leads, quotes and jobs are three different numbers

A lead site counts leads. You get paid for jobs. In between there's a lot of drop off.

  • A lead is a name and a job description. Sometimes it's real. Sometimes it's the wrong trade, too far away or never answers.

  • A quote is a lead you got hold of, went to see or priced up.

  • A job is a quote that said yes and paid.

Your real cost is everything you spent divided by the jobs at the end. Not the leads at the start.

The sum

Cost per job = everything you paid in the year ÷ jobs you won from it.

That's the start. Then add your time, because chasing dead leads isn't free either.

Real cost per job = (everything you paid + your hours chasing × what an hour of your time is worth) ÷ jobs won.

Worked example 1: a yearly membership

Say you pay £1,200 a year. That's the kind of figure trades report on review sites, though yours will be different.

  • Leads in the year: 12.

  • Ones you got hold of and quoted: 6.

  • Jobs won: 2.

£1,200 ÷ 2 = £600 per job, before your time. If each quote took two hours with the drive, that's 12 hours. At £40 an hour that's another £480. Real cost: £1,680 ÷ 2 = £840 per job.

If your average job is a £150 tap repair, that membership is losing you money. If it's a £9,000 bathroom, it might be fine. That's the point. Nobody can tell you if it's worth it except your own numbers.

Worked example 2: pay per lead

Say each lead costs £20 and goes to four other trades as well. You buy 50 leads in a year.

  • Spent: £1,000.

  • Customers who answered: 20.

  • Quotes: 12.

  • Jobs won: 3.

£1,000 ÷ 3 = £333 per job. Now add your time. Twelve quotes at two hours each is 24 hours. Chasing the 30 who never answered at 15 minutes each is another 7.5 hours. That's 31.5 hours, about £1,260 at £40 an hour. Real cost: £2,260 ÷ 3 = £753 per job.

Three jobs out of 50 leads might sound low. When the same job goes to five trades, though, four of them pay and lose every time.

What happens to a plumber's missed call, from ring to lost job

Why the numbers drop off so fast

Two things eat most leads.

Speed. On shared leads, trades say the job's gone before they've even seen the alert. Homeowners on those sites say their best experiences were replies within minutes. There's research behind it too. A study by MIT and InsideSales, published in Harvard Business Review in 2011, found that replying within five minutes made an enquiry 21 times more likely to become a real lead than replying after thirty minutes. If you're up a ladder when the alert comes in, you're already behind. More on that in the fastest reply wins the job.

Sharing. When one job goes to five trades, the customer often picks on price because that's all they've got to compare. We've written about that in one job sold to five trades.

Is a lead site worth it?

If you've typed "is Checkatrade worth it" into Google, the honest answer is the same sum. Membership is from £59 + VAT a month, then the leads. Put your real year into the cost per job sum above and you'll have your own answer. That beats anyone's opinion, ours included. There's a longer look in what a lead site costs against your own system.

Watch it: what a lead site costs before the leads, with the alternative priced.

Do the same sum on your own website

Fair is fair. Your own website isn't free either, so judge it the same way.

Our Basic plan is £799 a year paid once, for a Smart Website and an online job request form. The Full System is £1,600 a year and adds missed call text back, one inbox, AI chat that books, automatic reminders and review requests.

  • If Basic brings you four jobs in a year, that's about £200 per job.

  • If it brings you ten, it's about £80 per job.

  • If it brings you none, it's £799 of nothing and you should cancel.

We can't promise you a number. Be wary of anyone who does. The difference is what you're paying for. The enquiries aren't shared with four other trades. Nobody else gets the same alert. The reviews you collect go on your own Google profile and stay there.

The price never goes up for as long as you stay. There's no contract, you can cancel any time and there's a 30 day money back guarantee. See both plans on our pricing page.

Watch it: where the £27,000 a year missed call figure comes from.

Track it for one month

You can't do the sum without the numbers. Start tomorrow:

  1. Keep a note on your phone. One line per enquiry: date, where it came from, the job, quoted or not, won or not, value.

  2. Ask every new customer "where did you find us?" and write the answer down.

  3. At the end of the month, total what each source cost you.

  4. Divide by jobs won. Do it again after three months, because one month can be a fluke.

  5. Cut the source with the worst cost per job, or move that money somewhere it works harder.

A quick checklist

  • I know what I spent on each lead source last year.

  • I know how many jobs each one actually won me.

  • I've added my time, not just the fee.

  • I know my average job value and what I make on it.

  • I know the minimum term and exit fee on anything I'm signed up to. If not, read this before you sign a website or leads contract.

Questions trades ask

Are lead sites worth it for tradesmen?

For some trades, some of the time. On business forums, some trades say urgent work does better from them than big planned jobs. Your own cost per job against your average job value is the only real test.

How much should I pay per lead?

There's no right number, so work backwards. If you win one in five and you're happy paying £100 to win a job, you can afford £20 a lead. If you win one in ten, it's £10.

Why do leads never answer?

On review sites, trades describe fake or repeated job posts, customers who had already hired someone and people who posted to several sites at once and took the first reply. Speed helps with the last one. Nothing helps with the first two.

What's a good cost per job?

One you can afford out of the job's profit with plenty left over. If you make £300 on an average job and each job costs you £600 to win, the sum has already answered the question.

Charlie Jennett, founder of Chat Genius AI, at Rochester Cathedral in Kent

You deal with Charlie directly, a real person based in Medway. If you want to run your numbers past him before you change anything, book a quick call.

Charlie Jennett

Charlie Jennett

Founder of Chat Genius AI Ltd.

Back to Blog
↑